This is my second time ordering these plates. I ordered the first set in 2020. Seems that the finish is not as good as it used to be; much rougher and a less finished look. As far as the weight tolerances, I ordered 5 sets of 45’s and 1 set of 25’s. 9 of the 45’s were within .5 of the stated weight one was 45.8 which did surprise me. If you’re looking for a finished look that is more accurate I would order the deep dish plates. If I could do it over again I would have spent the extra 200 and went that route.

I only bought the 2.5lb plates of these to go with my Deep Dish Plates from Rogue. They are perfectly fine, but if you’re looking at these, just spend the extra money for the Rogue Deep Dish. You’ll thank me later! The price difference is negligible in my opinion and the quality difference is great. I asked my wife if she could tell which plates were not made in the USA from looking at them and she laughed. The Rogue plates are made in the USA, are higher quality, and look 100x better.

Accurate weight. Nice finish. Ordered over 300 pounds of these.

They're a good value, look awesome, do their job and sound great. However, they tend to slightly vary in size between batches meaning they do not sit evenly on the bar. The coat also sometimes comes off leaving spots where rust can accumalate. Still a great plate i would definitely buy again.

The first box I opened looked great, then I started to notice the painting was missing on letters. Then I opened this one and barely any are painted and what is painted is done very poorly

These are great plates - perfect for home gym! Well balanced with a nice finish. Very pleased with them

This is a single review from multiple years of buying these plates in different sizes: My initial batch of plates was right before the pandemic hit, those were all superb quality, price felt reasonable, no complaints. I added on a little between late 2020 and 2021 and the quality dipped noticeably for the latter ones with a couple issues (this was during a time period it was practically impossible to even buy plates to begin with from anywhere). The last pair of 45lb plates I got (last year) had some sort of alignment issue when cast/milled/or didn't get smoothed properly (given I believe these are imported that's not really Rogue's fault), leaving a sharp ridge around the bottom side of both of those plates. At the time I figured whatever and wrote it off as mostly cosmetic because it looks pretty innocent, but long term I ultimately wound up wishing I'd reached out about them as I've since cut myself and my leggings repeatedly while handling specifically those two. I keep them separated from the rest of my plates for that reason and only use if I must, which feels unfortunate given the cost. I'm sharing that as a consideration if it happens to anyone else as my opinion about Rogue overall is still really positive, any time I need to add on to my home gym this is where I look. The one time I did have to reach out about plate quality issues the customer service was fantastic, so I imagine it's possible they would've offered to rectify that pair of 45's had I reached out when I got them and not ignored it.

Olympic weight plates: simple, reliable, and indispensable for serious lifting. Nothing like that classic old school sound of iron. Get it.